| Vanessa Bayer | Self - Guest Host / Self / Self - Guest Co-Host | |
| Frank Iero | Self / Self - Death Spells | |
| Laura Jane Grace | Self | |
| Dave Hause | Self / Self - Guest Host | |
| Chris Gethard | Self | |
| Jenny Owen Youngs | Self / Self - Guest Host | |
| Brian Fallon | Self | |
| Jeremy Bolm | Self | |
| Jamie Kilstein | Self | |
| Julie Klausner | Self | |
| Chris Conley | Self | |
| Stephen Brodsky | Self | |
| Janeane Garofalo | Self | |
| Fat Mike | Self | |
| Matthew Caws | Self | |
| Frank Turner | Self | |
| Andrew W.K. | Self | |
| Matt Pond PA (Band) | Self | |
| Eugene Hutz | Self | |
| Jesse Malin (Band) | Self | |
| Paul Schneider | Self | |
| Joe Trohman | Self | |
| Juliya Chernetsky | Self | |
| William Beckett | Self | |
| Arturo Vega | Self | |
| Mat Devine | Self | |
| Jared Cotter | Self | |
| Adam Lazzara | Self | |
| Jim Shearer | Self | |
| Hunter Burgan | Self |
